skip to main |
skip to sidebar
NIGEL WATSON. THE Unknown DECEPTION: AN Quest OF THE Unknown Spasm Curiosity. In secret PUBLISHED, 2009. "Reviewed by Peter Rogerson."The sensation-seeking reader who is beguiled by the award in vogue concept that this book is promoting some caste of extraterrestrial conspiracy theory inner self be gloomily discontented, for it is a chock-full and basic hardship of the escalate of the abduction story. Nigel starts in the Hill abduction, and as a consequence draws in the assorted stuff which led to it. He chronicles the escalate of ideas in extraterrestrial flying saucers, the escalate of the speculation of contacting their pilots in the contactees and contactee groups of the 1950s, and the lengthy escalate of the abduction stories. He sees predecessors of these in the airship tales of the late 19th and preparatory 20th centuries (a matter of which he has completed a special re-evaluation), in the same way as tales of encounters and in some cases abductions by airship crews matured. These themes matured despondent adulthood high society, specially film (Nigel in altered change is a film umpire). But they are also based on other themes which Nigel examines in great detail, the speculation of being in use by the new in fairy-lore, where tales rack in vogue the late 18th and preparatory 19th centuries, Nigel gives some examples of these. Acquaint with also family in what were recognizable as imprisonment narratives, tales told by 'survivors' of tolerate odd human groups (Neighborhood Americans in America, Barbary pirates in Europe). Ended this weaving, sooner than a sincere secular register, Nigel shows how all these themes won over one altered and gave escalate to the new stiff. Nigel examines these new stories, and resume that that is directly what they are, stories, on a regular basis produced by third parties such as abduction hunters out of heaps of muddled "recording" on a regular basis shaped under hypnotic regression. Of actual not clear evidence offer is none (offer is, for prefigure, forever some rationale or other why abductions are never fixed on video or CCTV though assorted attempts to do this like been tried. Despite the fact that electorate of odd explanations can forever fastener some pathetic excuse for this, offer is no evidence to press us to harvest their designate of explanation, and heaps to stretch to us hill towards a psycho-social commentary. Assorted of the arguments in this book inner self, of course, be familiar to long-time Magonia readers, for sure it warrant well be regarded as the book of the Magonia position on such subjects, but for some readers this inner self be a new and confrontational commentary. This is an bulky book, and one which I bid (but I would, wouldn't I, as Nigel quotes from very a few of my articles?); though I recognise that offer are assorted play in the book's dealing (my on a plane is unpaginated) which warrant be stretch to it less charming than it have to be, and by chance have to act as a sign about the pitfalls of nucleus publishing, although conclusive how Nigel was let down by a progress to of publishers over the years of the book's gestation, I can see why he chose that way). "-- Peter Rogerson"
